Feeding Your Baby

How Combo Feeding Extended My Breastfeeding Journey Twice


Anjelika Temple here, mom to two forest mermaids, Anokhi (5.5) and Indira (3). I like long walks on the beach, ‘90s jams, and am a huge fan of parents making choices that are best for their families without judgment — especially when it comes to feeding. 

I breastfed both my daughters from day one. I was lucky enough to have two kiddos that latched easily, and my supply was just fine. Of course, that’s not all it takes to breastfeed. It takes time, it takes hours, it takes weird-tasting teas if your production is down— breastfeeding is a full-time job. With my first, Anokhi, I did what we all do with our first: I overachieved. I breastfed until she turned one. I pumped on planes, in Lyfts, and infamously in a Hulk-themed conference room at Marvel HQ. Part of such overachieving was making sure no one in the house was ever stressed about not having enough milk. Enter, baby formula! We introduced formula into the mix around six months with kid number one and it was like our entire household took a huge sigh of relief. If we had forgotten to thaw a bag of milk, it was *not* the end of the world. If my morning pump session only yielded four ounces, we would all survive. I don’t know why it felt like such an aha moment but it did — likely because of the pressure placed on moms to breastfeed way beyond what is possible with the million other things we need to do as conscious, intentional parents. 

With kid number two, Indira, we brought formula into the mix around the four-month mark. I had stockpiled about 70 ounces of breastmilk and then, due to wildfire season in Northern California, lost the entire stockpile after we were left without electricity for about a week. I even moved my milk to a commercial fridge after two days without power, but then they lost power, too! Having already done the combo feeding thing with Anokhi, it was an easy decision to make. And Indira LOVED it. She drank way more at a time from the bottle, started sleeping more, and, once again, I felt a huge weight lifted off my shoulders. 

Here are a few of the ways that formula was a key player in extending my breastfeeding journey:

  • Increased Milk Production: The craziest thing happened when we started supplementing with formula. My breastmilk production actually increased. It wasn’t just a matter of skipping a breastfeeding session and therefore having more breastmilk to pump, it actually coincided with me producing more ounces per day. And I think we all know why: Way less stress! All of a sudden, my baby’s health and nutrition did not depend solely on the milk I produced.
  • A Sense of Bodily Autonomy, for Everyone: There’s something pretty powerful about your kid knowing that when they are hungry and need to express it, there isn’t just ONE person that can help satisfy their hunger. It’s part of why I started pumping the week we got home from the hospital. We had hoped that breastfeeding would be part of our feeding journey, but also felt it was important for our babe to know that dada could also solve those hangry spells. Early on, there were plenty of times where I would be pumping at the exact same time my husband was feeding Anokhi. It felt insane and inefficient, but it meant that the moment we introduced bottles of formula into the mix, she was already used to the bottle and the transition was easy.
  • Sleep-Filled Nights: Letting go of the bedtime feed was pretty heartbreaking. What finally made it happen was a couple nights in a row where I had plans and my husband or our nanny did bedtime. Girlfriend took down NINE GLORIOUS OUNCES in one go and, boom, she slept through the night. I had noticed that after bedtime breastfeeding sessions, snuggly and warm as they were, she would fall asleep pretty quickly and I almost always had to pump about an hour later because she didn’t really drink much. Once we switched to formula at night, we were able to get much longer stretches of sleep on a consistent basis and I was able to wean myself off those late night pump sessions. Good for the whole family 🙂 

I breastfed Anokhi for 12 months and Indira for nine, and if this was an Oscar speech about successfully breastfeeding, the first person I would have to thank would be… FORMULA! Realizing that my feeding choice didn’t have to be all or nothing, that I didn’t have to choose one thing, that I didn’t have to give up on breastfeeding the moment I introduced formula — that is what extended my breastfeeding journey. Like so many realizations in parenthood, nothing is absolute. We can do it one way this month, get thrown a logistical wrench or two, educate ourselves, evolve, and do it another way next month. This flexibility with ourselves absolutely translates to our kiddos, and creates a space where we can all be more than one thing. In the case of Anokhi and Indira, they are both breastfed and formula-fed — and most importantly, they are healthy, open-minded, and loved!

The content on this site is for informational purposes only and not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Discuss any health or feeding concerns with your infant's pediatrician. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay it based on the content on this page.

The content on this site is for informational purposes only and not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Discuss any health or feeding concerns with your infant’s pediatrician. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay it based on the content on this page.

This post may contain affiliate links, and we may receive commissions for purchases made from this post.

Meet the Expert

Anjelika Temple

Anjelika Temple is an artist, writer, entrepreneur, and mom to two forest mermaids in Northern California. As the Co-Founder of Brit + Co, she spent a decade devoted to helping folks unlock their creativity, find courage and forge their own path. As Creative Director at Bobbie, Anj is focused on supporting and uplifting fellow parents through storytelling, community, and a deep dive into all things green. Follow her colorful adventures @anjelikatemple.

  • Milk Drunk Weekly

    Need a good read while you feed? Keep in the loop with the top pieces from the Milk Drunk team.